Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum

Current View: Recent Messages: dc385
(1900 Variant)

Messages:


New Post
List of Topics
Recent Messages


Preview:


Compact
Brief
Full


Replies:


Hide All
Show All

dc385 f05 results! - vonpowell   (Aug 23, 2011, 10:38 pm)
Mike,


 


As I read the orders, you are correct.  The Italian moves A
Mor-Spa and F Gib C A Mor-Spa are valid and unopposed.  The convoy
succeeds.


 


Yes, this is one of the limitations of Realpolitik when it comes to
1900.  I'm glad you caught this adjudication error.


 


Baron


=========




In a message dated 8/23/2011 1:08:43 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time,
mike(at)fuzzylogicllc.com writes:






By the way, the convoy of
Mor-Spain does succeed.  This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik
that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea
(alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy
order.  By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the
convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map.  But know
it's there in Spain!


 


"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an
army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and
prevent a fleet from entering."






From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue
8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh;
mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com;
jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com;
ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com;
dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!






Penner is officially eliminated, tho it
may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England
and Turkey going from 3 to 2...


 


BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon
Central...


 


Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1


Germany: Build 1


Italy: Build 1


Turkey: Remove 1



Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A
Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste -
Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St
Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania
- Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria


 


Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian
Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North
Sea


 


Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A
Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A
Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F
Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium -
Burgundy (*Bounce*)


 


Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco
- Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A
Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia -
Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia
(*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean -
Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A
Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia -
Palestine


 


Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya -
Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople
(*Fails*)


 

[Reply]

dc385 f05 results! - FuzzyLogic   (Aug 23, 2011, 3:04 pm)
By the way, the convoy of Mor-Spain does succeed.  This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea (alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy order.  By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map.  But know it's there in Spain!


 


"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and prevent a fleet from entering."






From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue 8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh; mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com; jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com; ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com; dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!






Penner is officially eliminated, tho it may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England and Turkey going from 3 to 2...


 


BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon Central...


 


Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1


Germany: Build 1


Italy: Build 1


Turkey: Remove 1



Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania - Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria


 


Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North Sea


 


Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium - Burgundy (*Bounce*)


 


Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia - Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia - Palestine


 


Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya - Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople (*Fails*)


 

[Reply]

dc385 f05 results! - FuzzyLogic   (Aug 23, 2011, 2:58 pm)
Penner is officially eliminated, tho it may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England and Turkey going from 3 to 2...


 


BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon Central...


 


Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1


Germany: Build 1


Italy: Build 1


Turkey: Remove 1



Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania - Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria


 


Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North Sea


 


Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium - Burgundy (*Bounce*)


 


Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia - Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia - Palestine


 


Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya - Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople (*Fails*)


 

[Reply]

dc385 f05 results! (dc385) FuzzyLogic Aug 23, 03:04 pm
By the way, the convoy of Mor-Spain does succeed.  This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea (alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy order.  By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map.  But know it's there in Spain!


 


"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and prevent a fleet from entering."






From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue 8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh; mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com; jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com; ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com; dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!






Penner is officially eliminated, tho it may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England and Turkey going from 3 to 2...


 


BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon Central...


 


Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1


Germany: Build 1


Italy: Build 1


Turkey: Remove 1



Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania - Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria


 


Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North Sea


 


Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium - Burgundy (*Bounce*)


 


Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia - Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia - Palestine


 


Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya - Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople (*Fails*)


 
dc385 f05 results! (dc385) vonpowell Aug 23, 10:38 pm
Mike,


 


As I read the orders, you are correct.  The Italian moves A
Mor-Spa and F Gib C A Mor-Spa are valid and unopposed.  The convoy
succeeds.


 


Yes, this is one of the limitations of Realpolitik when it comes to
1900.  I'm glad you caught this adjudication error.


 


Baron


=========




In a message dated 8/23/2011 1:08:43 P.M. Pacific Daylight Time,
mike(at)fuzzylogicllc.com writes:






By the way, the convoy of
Mor-Spain does succeed.  This seems to be a limitation of Realpolitik
that a space cannot be both coastal (allowing armies to enter) and sea
(alllowing fleets to convoy) thus RP considers it an invalid convoy
order.  By my read of the rules (www.dipwiki.com?title=1900) the
convoy is legal, so I'll move the army with the Winter map.  But know
it's there in Spain!


 


"Gibraltar is a sea space for convoy purposes, but an
army can move there from either Morocco (via the crossing arrow) or Spain, and
prevent a fleet from entering."






From: Michael Sims
Sent: Tue
8/23/2011 2:58 PM
To: Robert Stein
Cc: Douglas Fresh;
mvpenner(at)yahoo.com; MDemagogue(at)gmail.com; Knightofroma(at)hotmail.com;
jimmy.ghostine(at)vtmednet.org; jimmy.ghostine(at)gmail.com; mrh(at)panix.com;
ortuft(at)gmail.com; VonPowell(at)aol.com; dipping_chris(at)yahoo.com;
dc385
Subject: dc385 f05 results!






Penner is officially eliminated, tho it
may drop clear down to a 3-player game pretty quick here, with both England
and Turkey going from 3 to 2...


 


BUILDS... by Thu 8/25, 12 noon
Central...


 


Austria: Build 2
Britain: Remove 1


Germany: Build 1


Italy: Build 1


Turkey: Remove 1



Austria:
A St Petersburg Supports A
Finland
A Silesia - Warsaw
A Bohemia - Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Trieste -
Tyrolia (*Bounce*)
A Constantinople Hold
A Finland Supports A St
Petersburg
A Sevastopol - Armenia (*Fails*)
A Serbia Supports A Rumania
- Bulgaria
A Rumania - Bulgaria


 


Britain:
F Edinburgh - Norwegian
Sea
F Yorkshire - North Sea
F London Supports F Yorkshire - North
Sea


 


Germany:
F Denmark - Baltic Sea
A
Brest Hold
A Paris - Burgundy (*Bounce*)
A Cologne Supports A
Munich
A Berlin - Silesia
A Munich Supports A Berlin - Silesia
F
Norway Hold
F Sweden Supports F Norway
A Netherlands Hold
A Belgium -
Burgundy (*Bounce*)


 


Italy:
F Gibraltar Convoys A Morocco
- Spain (*Fails*)
A Liverpool Supports F North Atlantic Ocean - Clyde
A
Piedmont - Switzerland (*Fails*)
A Milan - Venetia
A Apulia -
Palestine
A Macedonia Supports A Constantinople
A Switzerland - Tyrolia
(*Bounce*)
A Morocco - Spain (*Fails*)
F North Atlantic Ocean -
Clyde
F Mid Atlantic Ocean - North Atlantic Ocean
F Ionian Sea Convoys A
Apulia - Palestine
F Eastern Mediterranean Convoys A Apulia -
Palestine


 


Turkey:
A Ankara Supports F Konya -
Constantinople
A Armenia - Sevastopol (*Fails*)
F Konya - Constantinople
(*Fails*)


 
Britain on vacation - Antikythera   (Jul 03, 2011, 1:59 pm)
Britain will be on vacation from the 4th of July until the 14th of July. My access to the net will be scanty, and replies to press may be slow.

Ole

[Reply]

Page:   1 

Rows per page:

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55336 · Page loaded in 0.1868 seconds by DESMOND