Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum:  dc302

(Standard)


Post:< 16292 >
Subject:< DC302 Clarification >
Topic:< dc302 >
Category:< Active Games >
Author:bielf11
Posted:May 17, 2010 at 2:25 pm
Viewed:1325 times

  [New Post]  [Reply]  [Quote]

Regardless whether he's regarded to be in CD or not, I think it's unfair to the other players to NMR. Worse, it shows no respect at all for two powers that have just been eliminated despite all their efforts to stay alive...  Sad


2010/5/17 Michael Thompson <psychosis(at)sky.com>

I've received a couple of queries as to Italy's status in the game, given an NMR from him for Fall 1906 moves and also for Winter 1906 adjustments.



This *doesn't* place Italy in Civil Disorder...in my house rules, I note that civil disorders are caused by two consecutive NMRs.  However, for the purposes of counting NMRs, Spring and Summer count as one season, and Fall, Autumn and Winter as another.  To trigger the two consecutive rule, a player needs to miss a move submission in Spring/Summer and then again in Fall/Autumn/Winter (or Fall/Autumn/Winter and then again in Spring/Summer) - so an NMR in Spring and then the lack of a retreat in Summer only counts as one NMR.  Or in the case of Italy recently, an NMR for Fall and then again for Winter only counts as one NMR.




Hope this makes sense.  I'll acknowledge that this isn't 100% clear in my rules, but this rule is a fairly standard one across the DC site...



Upshot of this is, Italy isn't in civil disorder, as his previous NMR was for Spring 1905.  However, if he misses Spring 1907 orders or any Summer 1907 retreats, then he will be placed in civil disorder.



Michael

This message is in reply to post 16279:

I've received a couple of queries as to Italy's status in the game, given an NMR from him for Fall 1906 moves and also for Winter 1906 adjustments.
This *doesn't* place Italy in Civil Disorder...in my house rules, I note that civil disorders are caused by two consecutive NMRs. However, for the purposes of counting NMRs, Spring and Summer count as one season, and Fall, Autumn and Winter as another. To trigger the two consecutive rule, a player needs to miss a move submission in Spring/Summer and then again in Fall/Autumn/Winter (or Fall/Autumn/Winter and then again in Spring/Summer) - so an NMR in Spring and then the lack of a retreat in Summer only counts as one NMR. Or in the case of Italy recently, an NMR for Fall and then again for Winter only counts as one NMR.
Hope this makes sense. I'll acknowledge that this isn't 100% clear in my rules, but this rule is a fairly standard one across the DC site...
Upshot of this is, Italy isn't in civil disorder, as his previous NMR was for Spring 1905. However, if he misses Spring 1907 orders or any Summer 1907 retreats, then he will be placed in civil disorder.
Michael



.

There are 4 Messages in this Thread:


DC302 Clarification (psychosis1973) May 17, 03:51 am

DC302 Clarification (bielf11) May 17, 02:25 pm

DC302 Clarification (Sean2010) May 17, 05:13 pm

DC302 Clarification (bielf11) May 17, 11:50 pm

There are 37 Threads in dc302:


DC302 EOG (Sean2010)

DC302 Game End Statement (Slangers)

DC302 (psychosis1973)

DC 302 Fall 1907 (psychosis1973)

DC 302 spring 1907 (psychosis1973) [3 Replies]

DC 302 spring 1907 reminder (psychosis1973)

DC302 Clarification (psychosis1973) [3 Replies]

DC302 Winter 1906 adjudication (psychosis1973)

DC302 Fall 1906 adjudication (psychosis1973) [4 Replies]

DC302 status (psychosis1973)

DC302 Fall 1905 adjudication (psychosis1973)

Dc302 Fall reminder (psychosis1973)

It's oh so quiet (Slangers)

DC302 - French envoy captured on its way to Russia (bielf11)

Dc302 Spring 1905 adjudication (psychosis1973) [9 Replies]

Dc302 Winter 1904 adjustments (psychosis1973)

Dc302 Fall 1904 adjudication (psychosis1973) [5 Replies]

DC302 - Germany on the brink of Civil Disorder (bielf11)

Dc302 Spring 1904 reminder (psychosis1973) [3 Replies]

Dc302 Spring 1904 (psychosis1973) [2 Replies]


1 - 20 of 37 shown [More]

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55604 · Page loaded in 0.3295 seconds by DESMOND