Welcome Guest!  [Log In]  [Sign Up]

Diplomaticcorp Discussion Forum:  dc300

(Magnificent Megalomania)


Post:< 15565 >
Subject:< DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication >
Topic:< dc300 >
Category:< Active Games >
Author:sunchung
Posted:Apr 13, 2010 at 10:11 am
Viewed:1079 times

  [New Post]  [Reply]  [Quote]

I vote in favor of an early decision, early vote.  Russia votes "Yes".  Is the best way for each player to individually write to you to say that they are voting for an early decision as well as what their vote is?

Sun

On Tue, Apr 13, 2010 at 7:27 AM, F Bielschowsky <bielschowsky.f-at-googlemail.com ([email]bielschowsky.f-at-googlemail.com[/email])> wrote:

Dirk,

I won't push up the deadline unless everyone confirms that they're okay with this. 
This way we prevent that someone is not around to confirm or submit orders before the original deadline.
Public votes are okay; secret votes of course too. After all, this is Diplomacy.


Frank


2010/4/13 Dirk Knemeyer <dirk-at-knemeyer.com ([email]dirk-at-knemeyer.com[/email])>
[quote:6f8f306dab]And if there is a secret no vote, Frank, can we possibly push up the fall adjudication? IF everyone gets their orders in can we just finish this?

Thanks,

Dirk



On Apr 13, 2010, at 10:18 AM, loganlaw299-at-aol.com ([email]loganlaw299-at-aol.com[/email]) wrote:

[quote:6f8f306dab] That just leaves Ben: perhaps Frank does not want us calling everyone out in public.  But just to make it clear France votes YES again.  Bruce


-----Original Message-----
From: Sun Chung <sun.chung-at-gmail.com ([email]sun.chung-at-gmail.com[/email])>
To: Dirk Knemeyer <dirk-at-knemeyer.com ([email]dirk-at-knemeyer.com[/email])>
Cc: loganlaw299-at-aol.com ([email]loganlaw299-at-aol.com[/email]); fisher.chrisw-at-gmail.com ([email]fisher.chrisw-at-gmail.com[/email]); sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com ([email]sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com[/email]); bielschowsky.f-at-gmail.com ([email]bielschowsky.f-at-gmail.com[/email]); dreamsynergy-at-hotmail.com ([email]dreamsynergy-at-hotmail.com[/email]); dc300-at-diplomaticcorp.com ([email]dc300-at-diplomaticcorp.com[/email])
Sent: Tue, Apr 13, 2010 8:14 am
Subject: Re: DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication

I've been voting yes as well.  Actually, for selfish reasons (to easily join another game) I need this game to finish first!  So I've been voting yes...  Russia votes "Yes" again.

On Tue, Apr 13, 2010 at 7:09 AM, Dirk Knemeyer <dirk-at-knemeyer.com ([email]dirk-at-knemeyer.com[/email])> wrote:
Hey Bruce,

I agree this is the most logical explanation but I've talked to Sun a fair amount in direct press and am pretty convinced he is NOT the one delaying it. That is the source of my frustration, I think it is happening either out of apathy or maybe somebody is just spiteful and trying to prove a point. I'm not sure. As has been pretty clearly illustrated, Russia WILL have the solo at the end of this year.

Dirk



On Apr 13, 2010, at 10:05 AM, loganlaw299-at-aol.com ([email]loganlaw299-at-aol.com[/email]) wrote:

I suspect that Sun - Russia - wants to achieve victory rather than have it handed to him, which is fine.  I will once again vote for EPG.  All of French forces will be holding in an attempt to bring peace to Europe and in recognition of the fine display of Russian arms and diplomacy.
Bruce


-----Original Message-----
From: Dirk Knemeyer <dirk-at-knemeyer.com ([email]dirk-at-knemeyer.com[/email])>
To: Christopher Fisher <fisher.chrisw-at-gmail.com ([email]fisher.chrisw-at-gmail.com[/email])>
Cc: Sean O'Donnell <sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com ([email]sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com[/email])>; Frank GM <bielschowsky.f-at-gmail.com ([email]bielschowsky.f-at-gmail.com[/email])>; Benjamin Sum <dreamsynergy-at-hotmail.com ([email]dreamsynergy-at-hotmail.com[/email])>; Bruce Logan <loganlaw299-at-aol.com ([email]loganlaw299-at-aol.com[/email])>; Sun Chung <sun.chung-at-gmail.com ([email]sun.chung-at-gmail.com[/email])>; DC <dc300-at-diplomaticcorp.com ([email]dc300-at-diplomaticcorp.com[/email])>
Sent: Tue, Apr 13, 2010 7:59 am
Subject: Re: DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication

Yes but it doesn't matter a damn what we all say publicly it just takes one to screw it up behind the scenes.

Dirk

On Apr 13, 2010, at 9:58 AM, Christopher Fisher wrote:

[quote:6f8f306dab]Do you vote in favor then, Dirk?

Chris

2010/4/13 Dirk Knemeyer <dirk-at-knemeyer.com ([email]dirk-at-knemeyer.com[/email])>
I tried pleading for a vote last season. Somebody is poisoning the > well. I have zero faith in an EGP passing this season no matter how > strenuously it is argued for.

Dirk



On Apr 13, 2010, at 9:39 AM, Christopher Fisher wrote:

You missed Liverpool, also a Russian province at the moment. We're > looking at 19 centers at the close of this year!

Chris

2010/4/13 Sean O'Donnell <sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com ([email]sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com[/email])>
Chris has a point. I would also point out that Russia will attain > his 18 supply centers; provided, I'm not miss counting/Russia makes > an monumental error.

Nwy, Swe, Den= 3
Mos, Stp, War, Sev= 4
7

Ber, Kie, Mun= 3
Vie and Bud= 2
5

Ser, Rum, Bul= 3
Con, Ank, Smy= 3
6
7+5+6= 18

I believe that Russia has attained the ability to attain the 18 > centers needed to win outright.

from Sean

Date: Tue, 13 Apr 2010 14:52:50 +0800
Subject: Re: DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication
From: fisher.chrisw-at-gmail.com ([email]fisher.chrisw-at-gmail.com[/email])
To: bielschowsky.f-at-gmail.com ([email]bielschowsky.f-at-gmail.com[/email])
CC: dreamsynergy-at-hotmail.com ([email]dreamsynergy-at-hotmail.com[/email]); loganlaw299-at-aol.com ([email]loganlaw299-at-aol.com[/email]); > dirk-at-knemeyer.com ([email]dirk-at-knemeyer.com[/email]); sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com ([email]sean_o_donnell-at-hotmail.com[/email]); sun.chung-at-gmail.com ([email]sun.chung-at-gmail.com[/email]); dc300-at-diplomaticcorp.com ([email]dc300-at-diplomaticcorp.com[/email])


Frank, I'd like to propose yet another EGP for a Russian solo. Is > there any way to decide on the EGP prior to the adjudication? My > vote goes for the Russian solo.

Guys, lets just get this over with and move on to the next game. > There is no way to prevent a solo at this point as Russia is not > under any sort of threat to lose an SC. That will put him at 18. If > you didn't send in a vote in the past please do so now, it will save > everyone some time and Frank the trouble of compiling another > adjudication.

Chris
Turkey

2010/4/13 F Bielschowsky <bielschowsky.f-at-googlemail.com ([email]bielschowsky.f-at-googlemail.com[/email])>
Spring 1906: the Powers tried again to bring an end to this war but > failed once more.
The Russian Solo EGP was rejected.
And thus the war continues...
...the Turks flee Smyrna fearing a full-blown attack from the > Russians. The Russians however only ordered their fleet in > Constantinople to Smyrna; it appears that they had the right intel.
The French army in Belgium gets squeezed between the Germans and own > troops and has to disband. And if the French fleet hadn't moved out > of Marseille, the Italians would have done that by force. They are a > bit more fortunate in the south and take Tunis; a look at the map > though shows that its occupation may not last very long.
Not sure whether the Germans will be celebrating their capture of > Belgium because the Russians overtook Denmark and Berlin.
No retreats required.

Adjudication
------------------
England:
F London - North Sea (*Fails*)
F North Sea - Edinburgh (*Bounce*)

France:
A Belgium Supports A Paris - Burgundy (*Disbanded*)
F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic Ocean (*Bounce*)
F Marseilles - Spain(sc)
A Paris - Burgundy (*Fails*)
A Picardy Supports A Belgium (*Cut*)
F Western Mediterranean - Tunis

Germany:
A Burgundy - Picardy (*Fails*)
A Holland - Belgium
A Ruhr Supports A Holland - Belgium
F Yorkshire - Edinburgh (*Bounce*)

Italy:
A Greece Hold
F Gulf of Lyon - Marseilles
F Naples - Tyrrhenian Sea
F North Africa - Mid-Atlantic Ocean (*Bounce*)
A Piedmont Supports F Gulf of Lyon - Marseilles
F Tyrrhenian Sea - Western Mediterranean

Russia:
A Armenia Hold
F Baltic Sea Supports A Sweden - Denmark
F Black Sea - Constantinople
A Bohemia Supports A Munich
A Bulgaria Hold
F Constantinople - Smyrna
F Liverpool - Irish Sea
A Moscow - Prussia (*Fails*)
A Munich Hold
F Norway - Sweden
A Prussia - Berlin
A Silesia Supports A Munich
F St Petersburg(nc) - Norway
A Sweden - Denmark
A Warsaw - Prussia

Turkey:
F Smyrna - Eastern Mediterranean

Deadline for Fall 1906 orders is Monday April 19 at 17:00 GMT.
No EGP up for voting this Fall. EGPs are welcome at any time.

Frank


The New Busy is not the old busy. Search, chat and e-mail from your > inbox. Get started.






[/quote:6f8f306dab]


[/quote:6f8f306dab]




[/quote:6f8f306dab]

This message is in reply to post 15533:

Spring 1906: the Powers tried again to bring an end to this war but failed once more.
The Russian Solo EGP was rejected.
And thus the war continues...
...the Turks flee Smyrna fearing a full-blown attack from the Russians. The Russians however only ordered their fleet in Constantinople to Smyrna; it appears that they had the right intel.
The French army in Belgium gets squeezed between the Germans and own troops and has to disband. And if the French fleet hadn't moved out of Marseille, the Italians would have done that by force. They are a bit more fortunate in the south and take Tunis; a look at the map though shows that its occupation may not last very long.
Not sure whether the Germans will be celebrating their capture of Belgium because the Russians overtook Denmark and Berlin.
No retreats required.
 
Adjudication
------------------
England:
F London - North Sea (*Fails*)
F North Sea - Edinburgh (*Bounce*)
 
France:
A Belgium Supports A Paris - Burgundy (*Disbanded*)
F English Channel - Mid-Atlantic Ocean (*Bounce*)
F Marseilles - Spain(sc)
A Paris - Burgundy (*Fails*)
A Picardy Supports A Belgium (*Cut*)
F Western Mediterranean - Tunis
 
Germany:
A Burgundy - Picardy (*Fails*)
A Holland - Belgium
A Ruhr Supports A Holland - Belgium
F Yorkshire - Edinburgh (*Bounce*)
 
Italy:
A Greece Hold
F Gulf of Lyon - Marseilles
F Naples - Tyrrhenian Sea
F North Africa - Mid-Atlantic Ocean (*Bounce*)
A Piedmont Supports F Gulf of Lyon - Marseilles
F Tyrrhenian Sea - Western Mediterranean
 
Russia:
A Armenia Hold
F Baltic Sea Supports A Sweden - Denmark
F Black Sea - Constantinople
A Bohemia Supports A Munich
A Bulgaria Hold
F Constantinople - Smyrna
F Liverpool - Irish Sea
A Moscow - Prussia (*Fails*)
A Munich Hold
F Norway - Sweden
A Prussia - Berlin
A Silesia Supports A Munich
F St Petersburg(nc) - Norway
A Sweden - Denmark
A Warsaw - Prussia
 
Turkey:
F Smyrna - Eastern Mediterranean
 
Deadline for Fall 1906 orders is Monday April 19 at 17:00 GMT.
No EGP up for voting this Fall. EGPs are welcome at any time.
 
Frank

There are 18 Messages in this Thread:


DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (bielf11) Apr 12, 02:24 pm

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (cfisher6) Apr 13, 01:52 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (Sean2010) Apr 13, 08:28 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (Sean2010) Apr 13, 08:28 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (cfisher6) Apr 13, 08:39 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (dknemeyer) Apr 13, 08:48 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (cfisher6) Apr 13, 08:57 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (dknemeyer) Apr 13, 08:59 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (Stabback) Apr 13, 09:06 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (dknemeyer) Apr 13, 09:09 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (sunchung) Apr 13, 09:14 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (Stabback) Apr 13, 09:19 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (dknemeyer) Apr 13, 09:21 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (cfisher6) Apr 13, 09:22 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (bielf11) Apr 13, 09:57 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (sunchung) Apr 13, 10:11 am

DC300 - Spring 1906 adjudication (Sean2010) Apr 13, 10:26 am

A simple solution to the mystery (txurce) Apr 13, 02:46 pm

Diplomacy games may contain lying, stabbing, or deliberately deceiving communications that may not be suitable for and may pose a hazard to young children, gullible adults, and small farm animals.

Powered by Fuzzy Logic · You are visitor number 55500 · Page loaded in 0.6872 seconds by DESMOND